This is a purely informative rendering of an RFC that includes verified errata. This rendering may not be used as a reference.

The following 'Verified' errata have been incorporated in this document: EID 5578
Network Working Group                                       E. Levinson
Request for Comments: 2387                                  August 1998
Obsoletes: 2112
Category: Standards Track


                The MIME Multipart/Related Content-type

Status of this Memo

   This document specifies an Internet standards track protocol for the
   Internet community, and requests discussion and suggestions for
   improvements.  Please refer to the current edition of the "Internet
   Official Protocol Standards" (STD 1) for the standardization state
   and status of this protocol.  Distribution of this memo is unlimited.

Copyright Notice

   Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1998).  All Rights Reserved.

Abstract

   The Multipart/Related content-type provides a common mechanism for
   representing objects that are aggregates of related MIME body parts.
   This document defines the Multipart/Related content-type and provides
   examples of its use.

1.  Introduction

   Several applications of MIME, including MIME-PEM, and MIME-Macintosh
   and other proposals, require multiple body parts that make sense only
   in the aggregate.  The present approach to these compound objects has
   been to define specific multipart subtypes for each new object.  In
   keeping with the MIME philosophy of having one mechanism to achieve
   the same goal for different purposes, this document describes a
   single mechanism for such aggregate or compound objects.

   The Multipart/Related content-type addresses the MIME representation
   of compound objects.  The object is categorized by a "type"
   parameter.  Additional parameters are provided to indicate a specific
   starting body part or root and auxiliary information which may be
   required when unpacking or processing the object.

   Multipart/Related MIME entities may contain Content-Disposition
   headers that provide suggestions for the storage and display of a
   body part.  Multipart/Related processing takes precedence over
   Content-Disposition; the interaction between them is discussed in
   section 4.

   Responsibility for the display or processing of a Multipart/Related's
   constituent entities rests with the application that handles the
   compound object.

2.  Multipart/Related Registration Information

   The following form is copied from RFC 1590, Appendix A.

     To:  IANA@isi.edu
     Subject:  Registration of new Media Type content-type/subtype

     Media Type name:           Multipart

     Media subtype name:        Related

     Required parameters:       Type, a media type/subtype.

     Optional parameters:       Start
                                Start-info

     Encoding considerations:   Multipart content-types cannot have
                                encodings.

     Security considerations:   Depends solely on the referenced type.

     Published specification:   RFC-REL (this document).

     Person & email address to contact for further information:
                                Edward Levinson
                                47 Clive Street
                                Metuchen, NJ  08840-1060
                                +1 908 494 1606
                                XIson@cnj.digex.net

3.  Intended usage

   The Multipart/Related media type is intended for compound objects
   consisting of several inter-related body parts.  For a
   Multipart/Related object, proper display cannot be achieved by
   individually displaying the constituent body parts.  The content-type
   of the Multipart/Related object is specified by the type parameter.
   The "start" parameter, if given, points, via a content-ID, to the
   body part that contains the object root.  The default root is the
   first body part within the Multipart/Related body.

   The relationships among the body parts of a compound object
   distinguishes it from other object types.  These relationships are
   often represented by links internal to the object's components that

   reference the other components.  Within a single operating
   environment the links are often file names, such links may be
   represented within a MIME message using content-IDs or the value of
   some other "Content-" headers.

3.1.  The Type Parameter

   The type parameter must be specified and its value is the MIME media
   type of the "root" body part.  It permits a MIME user agent to
   determine the content-type without reference to the enclosed body
   part.  If the value of the type parameter and the root body part's
   content-type differ then the User Agent's behavior is undefined.

3.2.  The Start Parameter

   The start parameter, if given, is the content-ID of the compound
   object's "root".  If not present the "root" is the first body part in
   the Multipart/Related entity.  The "root" is the element the
   applications processes first.

3.3.  The Start-Info Parameter

   Additional information can be provided to an application by the
   start-info parameter.  It contains either a string or points, via a
   content-ID, to another MIME entity in the message.  A typical use
   might be to provide additional command line parameters or a MIME
   entity giving auxiliary information for processing the compound
   object.

   Applications that use Multipart/Related must specify the
   interpretation of start-info.  User Agents shall provide the
   parameter's value to the processing application.  Processes can
   distinguish a start-info reference from a token or quoted-string by
   examining the first non-white-space character, "<" indicates a
   reference.

3.4.  Syntax

          related-param   := ( ";" "type"  "=" type "/" subtype ) 
                        [ ";" "start" "=" cid ]
                        [ ";" "start-info"  "="
                           ( cid-list / value ) ]
                        ; order independent, "type" is required
EID 5578 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 0.4

Original Text:

     related-param   := [ ";" "start" "=" cid ]
                        [ ";" "start-info"  "="
                           ( cid-list / value ) ]
                        [ ";" "type"  "=" type "/" subtype ]
                        ; order independent

Corrected Text:

     related-param   := ( ";" "type"  "=" type "/" subtype )
                        [ ";" "start" "=" cid ]
                        [ ";" "start-info"  "="
                           ( cid-list / value ) ]
                        ; order independent, "type" is required
Notes:
The "type" parameter is specified by the rest of the document to be mandatory, but the ABNF in section 3.4 indicates that it is optional. Even though the ABNF is specified somewhat informally (and arguably should be formalized if this RFC is ever re-issued), it should not be giving information that contradicts the formal part of the specification (e.g., section 2).

===== Verifier notes =====
As the reporter says, the ABNF here needs more work, and that should be held for document update. This particular item, though, does, indeed, contradict the normative text. I have also moved the required item to the top of the parameter list for clarity.
cid-list := cid cid-list cid := msg-id ; c.f. [822] value := token / quoted-string ; c.f. [MIME] ; value cannot begin with "<" Note that the parameter values will usually require quoting. Msg-id contains the special characters "<", ">", "@", and perhaps other special characters. If msg-id contains quoted-strings, those quote marks must be escaped. Similarly, the type parameter contains the special character "/". 4. Handling Content-Disposition Headers Content-Disposition Headers [DISP] suggest presentation styles for MIME body parts. [DISP] describes two presentation styles, called the disposition type, INLINE and ATTACHMENT. These, used within a multipart entity, allow the sender to suggest presentation information. [DISP] also provides for an optional storage (file) name. Content-Disposition headers could appear in one or more body parts contained within a Multipart/Related entity. Using Content-Disposition headers in addition to Multipart/Related provides presentation information to User Agents that do not recognize Multipart/Related. They will treat the multipart as Multipart/Mixed and they may find the Content-Disposition information useful. With Multipart/Related however, the application processing the compound object determines the presentation style for all the contained parts. In that context the Content-Disposition header information is redundant or even misleading. Hence, User Agents that understand Multipart/Related shall ignore the disposition type within a Multipart/Related body part. It may be possible for a User Agent capable of handling both Multipart/Related and Content-Disposition headers to provide the invoked application the Content-Disposition header's optional filename parameter to the Multipart/Related. The use of that information will depend on the specific application and should be specified when describing the handling of the corresponding compound object. Such descriptions would be appropriate in an RFC registering that object's media type. 5. Examples 5.1 Application/X-FixedRecord The X-FixedRecord content-type consists of one or more octet-streams and a list of the lengths of each record. The root, which lists the record lengths of each record within the streams. The record length list, type Application/X-FixedRecord, consists of a set of INTEGERs in ASCII format, one per line. Each INTEGER gives the number of octets from the octet-stream body part that constitute the next "record". The example below, uses a single data block. Content-Type: Multipart/Related; boundary=example-1 start="<950120.aaCC@XIson.com>"; type="Application/X-FixedRecord" start-info="-o ps" --example-1 Content-Type: Application/X-FixedRecord Content-ID: <950120.aaCC@XIson.com> 25 10 34 10 25 21 26 10 --example-1 Content-Type: Application/octet-stream Content-Description: The fixed length records Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-ID: <950120.aaCB@XIson.com> T2xkIE1hY0RvbmFsZCBoYWQgYSBmYXJtCkUgSS BFIEkgTwpBbmQgb24gaGlzIGZhcm0gaGUgaGFk IHNvbWUgZHVja3MKRSBJIEUgSSBPCldpdGggYS BxdWFjayBxdWFjayBoZXJlLAphIHF1YWNrIHF1 YWNrIHRoZXJlLApldmVyeSB3aGVyZSBhIHF1YW NrIHF1YWNrCkUgSSBFIEkgTwo= --example-1-- 5.2 Text/X-Okie The Text/X-Okie is an invented markup language permitting the inclusion of images with text. A feature of this example is the inclusion of two additional body parts, both picture. They are referred to internally by the encapsulated document via each picture's body part content-ID. Usage of "cid:", as in this example, may be useful for a variety of compound objects. It is not, however, a part of the Multipart/Related specification. Content-Type: Multipart/Related; boundary=example-2; start="<950118.AEBH@XIson.com>" type="Text/x-Okie" --example-2 Content-Type: Text/x-Okie; charset=iso-8859-1; declaration="<950118.AEB0@XIson.com>" Content-ID: <950118.AEBH@XIson.com> Content-Description: Document {doc} This picture was taken by an automatic camera mounted ... {image file=cid:950118.AECB@XIson.com} {para} Now this is an enlargement of the area ... {image file=cid:950118:AFDH@XIson.com} {/doc} --example-2 Content-Type: image/jpeg Content-ID: <950118.AFDH@XIson.com> Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64 Content-Description: Picture A [encoded jpeg image] --example-2 Content-Type: image/jpeg Content-ID: <950118.AECB@XIson.com> Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64 Content-Description: Picture B [encoded jpeg image] --example-2-- 5.3 Content-Disposition In the above example each image body part could also have a Content- Disposition header. For example, --example-2 Content-Type: image/jpeg Content-ID: <950118.AECB@XIson.com> Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64 Content-Description: Picture B Content-Disposition: INLINE [encoded jpeg image] --example-2-- User Agents that recognize Multipart/Related will ignore the Content-Disposition header's disposition type. Other User Agents will process the Multipart/Related as Multipart/Mixed and may make use of that header's information. 6. User Agent Requirements User agents that do not recognize Multipart/Related shall, in accordance with [MIME], treat the entire entity as Multipart/Mixed. MIME User Agents that do recognize Multipart/Related entities but are unable to process the given type should give the user the option of suppressing the entire Multipart/Related body part shall be. Existing MIME-capable mail user agents (MUAs) handle the existing media types in a straightforward manner. For discrete media types (e.g. text, image, etc.) the body of the entity can be directly passed to a display process. Similarly the existing composite subtypes can be reduced to handing one or more discrete types. Handling Multipart/Related differs in that processing cannot be reduced to handling the individual entities. The following sections discuss what information the processing application requires. It is possible that an application specific "receiving agent" will manipulate the entities for display prior to invoking actual application process. Okie, above, is an example of this; it may need a receiving agent to parse the document and substitute local file names for the originator's file names. Other applications may just require a table showing the correspondence between the local file names and the originator's. The receiving agent takes responsibility for such processing. 6.1 Data Requirements MIME-capable mail user agents (MUAs) are required to provide the application: (a) the bodies of the MIME entities and the entity Content-* headers, (b) the parameters of the Multipart/Related Content-type header, and (c) the correspondence between each body's local file name, that body's header data, and, if present, the body part's content-ID. 6.2 Storing Multipart/Related Entities The Multipart/Related media type will be used for objects that have internal linkages between the body parts. When the objects are stored the linkages may require processing by the application or its receiving agent. 6.3 Recursion MIME is a recursive structure. Hence one must expect a Multipart/Related entity to contain other Multipart/Related entities. When a Multipart/Related entity is being processed for display or storage, any enclosed Multipart/Related entities shall be processed as though they were being stored. 6.4 Configuration Considerations It is suggested that MUAs that use configuration mechanisms, see [CFG] for an example, refer to Multipart/Related as Multi- part/Related/<type>, were <type> is the value of the "type" parameter. 7. Security Considerations Security considerations relevant to Multipart/Related are identical to those of the underlying content-type. 8. Acknowledgments This proposal is the result of conversations the author has had with many people. In particular, Harald A. Alvestrand, James Clark, Charles Goldfarb, Gary Houston, Ned Freed, Ray Moody, and Don Stinchfield, provided both encouragement and invaluable help. The author, however, take full responsibility for all errors contained in this document. 9. References [822] Crocker, D., "Standard for the Format of ARPA Internet Text Messages", STD 11, RFC 822, August 1982. [CID] Levinson, E., and J. Clark, "Message/External-Body Content-ID Access Type", RFC 1873, December 1995, Levinson, E., "Message/External-Body Content-ID Access Type", Work in Progress. [CFG] Borenstein, N., "A User Agent Configuration Mechanism For Multimedia Mail Format Information", RFC 1524, September 1993. [DISP] Troost, R., and S. Dorner, "Communicating Presentation Information in Internet Messages: The Content- Disposition Header", RFC 1806, June 1995. [MIME] Borenstein, N., and Freed, N., "Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions (MIME) Part One: Format of Internet Message Bodies", RFC 2045, November 1996. 9. Author's Address Edward Levinson 47 Clive Street Metuchen, NJ 08840-1060 USA Phone: +1 908 494 1606 EMail: XIson@cnj.digex.com 10. Changes from previous draft (RFC 2112) Corrected cid urls to conform to RFC 2111; the angle brackets were removed. 11. Full Copyright Statement Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1998). All Rights Reserved. This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it or assist in its implementation may be prepared, copied, published and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are included on all such copies and derivative works. However, this document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other Internet organizations, except as needed for the purpose of developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process must be followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than English. The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns. This document and the information contained herein is provided on an "AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.